Listed with graduating class and the years each earned All-American honors. An asterisk (*) denotes a National Prep championship.
Mason Chamberlain '292026
Chase Hetrick '282026
Rocco Lombardo '292026
Evan Cies '292026
Matt O'Neill '282024, 2025*, 2026
Declan O'Byrne '272025, 2026
Lukas Zalota '272024, 2026*
Ray Fitzgerald '272025, 2026
Justin Farnsworth '272024, 2025, 2026*
Stevie Smith '272025
Jack Chamberlain '262024
Lukas Littleton Mascaro '262023*, 2024, 2026*
Brendan Kelly '262024, 2025
Tyler Conroy '262023, 2025, 2026
Matt Connolly '262024
Stosh Zalota '252022, 2023, 2024
Jason Torres '252024, 2025
Anthony Mutarelli '252022*
Philip Tabasso '242023
Nick Wehmeyer '242023, 2024
Nick O'Neill '242021, 2022, 2023, 2024
Jack Consiglio '242021*, 2022, 2023*, 2024*
Nathan Rickards '242022, 2023, 2024
Sean Patrick O'Donnell '232022, 2023
Spencer Barnhart '232021*, 2022, 2023
Reed Fullmer '232021, 2022, 2023
Tommy Link '232020, 2021, 2022, 2023
Isaiah Wright '222022
Owen Quinn '222021, 2022
Jack Wehmeyer '222019, 2020, 2021*, 2022
Caden Rogers '222019, 2020, 2021*, 2022
Andrew Connolly '222019, 2020, 2021, 2022
Nicholas Feldman '222019, 2020*, 2021*, 2022*
Coltin Deery '222020*, 2021*
Josh Viarengo '212021
Owen Vietmeier '212020
Dayton Delviscio '202018, 2019, 2020
Dalton Harkins '202017, 2018, 2019, 2020*
Nicholas Florschutz '192016, 2017, 2018, 2019
Henry Hague '192017, 2018
Shane Hanson-Ashworth '192016, 2017
Mark Salvatore '182015, 2017, 2018
PJ Crane '182016, 2017, 2018
Chris Hisey '182018
Michael Beard '182015, 2016*, 2017*, 2018*
Brendan Devine '182018
Ryan Karoly '182016*, 2017*
Jeff Klenk '172017
Seth Janey '172016*, 2017*
Nick Lattanze '162013, 2014, 2015, 2016
Matt Lattanze '162013, 2014, 2015, 2016
Benjamin Tuohey '162016
Rashon Lusane '162015, 2016
Jake Anderson '142013, 2014*
Harry Mauk '132011, 2013
Greg Bacci '132012, 2013
Connor Burns '132012, 2013
Alfredo Giannaccari '132012
Jimmy (James) Stowell '122009, 2011
Rick Durso '112009, 2010, 2011
Robert Scaramuzza '112010
Joseph DiTrollo '102010
Andrew Giannascoli '092009
Neil Willis '092008, 2009
Craig Whitaker '052005
Nick Salvo '042003, 2004
Matt Intoccia '042003, 2004
Todd Brennan '001999, 2000
Grant Shanaman '971997
Reed Shanaman1997
Derek Donegan '951994, 1995
Eustace Mita '951995
Hunter Jones '921991
Terry Gallagher '901988, 1989, 1990*
Anthony Tabasso '891989
Brendon Melody '871987
Jim Patton '871987
Tommy Jones '801980
Chris Smykal '771976, 1977*
Bill Bennett '731973
